DH Banner
Home Features Reviews Manager Columns Whitepapers Buyer's Guide
Login Forgotten Details?
Become a Member
Newsletter Search  
Password
All the right signals

All the right signals

Don’t get your wires crossed walking the line of the mobile warrior—choose the wireless option that can dodge your wireless pits to keep you on 24x7. By Kire Terzievski and Michael Palamountain, Enex TestLab
Other pages in the review
 
EDITORS CHOICE WINNER-TELSTRA

3

3 makes use of a Novatel Merlin U630 quad-band wireless card compatible with GSM/GPRS and 3G networks. The demonstration device shipped with a setup CD and a clear plastic case for the card all contained within a DVD case complete with CD holder. A 3 SIM slots into the side of the card and a small latch allows for its easy removal as required.  A five-inch external aerial is supplied with the device; this can be attached with Velcro to the case of your laptop.

It took a while to install this card but it did not cause any serious problems apart from the lack of a progress indicator—we were given no indication as to when we should plug in the card itself. For want of further instructions we plugged in the card after software installation and activated the desktop icon. Here we were presented with a control dashboard looking somewhat like a section of a mobile phone. The dash provides for email and browser launching; network configuration options and status displays are also present.

 

Coverage and plans

3 offers 3G services similar to that supplied by Optus and Vodafone. There is reasonable coverage in most state capitals and a few regional centres; beyond this range customers have the option to fallback onto Telstra’s GPRS network. Three plans are offered (should we be surprised there are three plans?), each with the same speed but differing in the amount of data included. Excess data costs are reasonable unless you stray out of the 3G service range, at which point you are billed at a significantly higher rate for a slower service.

Performance

In our tests download speed was somewhat slower than expected but upload speeds were reasonable. The nominal service speed is 384/64Kbps and we recorded an average of 187/54Kbps. In defence of 3 we recorded 335/59Kbps on a shorter test in May which is quite respectable. It scored poorly in our latency tests, scoring about 2.1 seconds; availability was very good at 99.7 percent.

We should also note that the throughput rates were very consistent over time,  apart from a short time towards the end of our testing. As noted earlier there is any number of factors which could account for this variation, one possibility that comes to mind is the adverse effect of the poor average latency score of about 2.1 seconds; some providers managed latency scores down to one 10th of this amount—which is more like what one normally hopes for.

Overall, standard 3G cards offer limited flexibility in terms of speed and we found the expected speed a little unreliable at our test site. Nonetheless the card and associated services are reasonably priced and there are no serious faults to be found in service provision.

   Previous Page  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next Page   

  Product comparison and link to details
  ProductPrice RatingCompare
$0 on all 18 month plans. 
***
$250 
***
$240 or $10/month over 2yrs 
****
$299 
****
$249 
***
$299 
***
Columns
What is stopping you from immediately upgrading to Windows Vista?
staff training costs
application incompatibility
upgrading technical specs
would rather wait for SP1
all of the above
I use Mac
Columns
Straight to the Source Microsoft is making its push into the middle market, first in the US and now here. This is what analysts... More
Columns
Helpfile In this workshop, we take a quick look at how to hit the ground running when developing cross-platform interfaces... More
Columns